Written by Paola Piazzi

With HPAPI dust, a cartridge filter may not be enough. When an absolute filter is needed and how to replace it safely with a bag-in/bag-out system.

In the pharmaceutical industry, many active ingredients are effective at very low doses: the same potency that makes them useful in therapy makes them dangerous for anyone who breathes them in during production. These are HPAPIs (Highly Potent Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients), substances whose permitted exposure levels can be as low as a few micrograms per cubic metre of air, or even lower: amounts invisible to the naked eye.

Dispensing, blending, transfer, compression and packaging all generate airborne dust, and the more potent the substance, the stricter the containment targets become. The issue is not only how much dust is produced, but what kind.

This is why the industry invests in isolators and closed systems that separate the operator from the product. But anyone designing pharmaceutical machinery also needs to ask another question: what happens to the air extracted from the machine? That air must be filtered too and, when the substance, the destination of the air or the risk assessment require it, an absolute filter is needed as a second barrier downstream of the main filter.

How much dust can a worker breathe?

The permitted amount is defined by the occupational exposure limit (OEL): the airborne concentration of a substance to which a worker can be exposed during a shift, according to the criteria adopted for that substance. For highly potent active ingredients, these values can be extremely low.

Many pharmaceutical companies group substances into occupational exposure bands (OEBs): the higher the band, the lower the limit and the stricter the measures required of the machine and the system. The thresholds for each band may vary from one company to another.

With containment targets this demanding, the way filtration is designed changes: removing most of the dust is not enough, and the entire air path must be sized for the required level of protection.

How is the operator protected during pharmaceutical production?

The first barrier is created directly around the process, with isolators, hoods, closed systems and local exhaust ventilation that prevent or reduce the spread of dust into the working environment.

For a pharmaceutical machine builder, this is a central issue. The end customer sets containment and performance requirements that the machine must help achieve. Extraction and filtration are therefore not separate from the process: they are an integral part of the containment strategy of the machine or line.

What happens to the air extracted from an isolator or a closed machine?

Air extracted from a closed machine can carry particles of the processed product with it: this is why its path is as much a part of the containment problem as the machine itself.

Imagine a fully closed machine. The dust stays inside and the operator is separated from the process. To maintain certain internal conditions, however, it may be necessary to extract air, and with it part of the product.

At that point, three questions arise:

  • where is the air conveyed?
  • how is it filtered?
  • what happens before it is returned to the department or discharged outside?

Good containment upstream must be matched by equally rigorous management of the extracted air downstream.

Is a cartridge filter enough for pharmaceutical dust?

A properly sized cartridge filter captures a very high share of the dust and remains the main stage of the system; in the most critical pharmaceutical applications, however, a second absolute filtration stage may be needed downstream.

There are two reasons for this.

The first concerns residual concentration. With substances that require extremely low containment levels, even a very small residual concentration downstream of the main filter must be assessed against the requirements of the application.

The second concerns anomalies. A cartridge can deteriorate or become damaged: without a further stage, a loss of containment would go straight into the downstream airflow. The consequences may affect the protection of people, emissions control and, where relevant, the risk of process contamination.

This is why, in certain applications, a second filtration barrier is provided.

What is an absolute filter and how does HEPASAFE work?

An absolute filter (or HEPA filter) is a very high-efficiency filtration stage designed to capture very fine solid particles; in an extraction system it is installed downstream of the primary filtration as a second barrier. In Europe, HEPA filter efficiency classes are defined by the EN 1822 standard: class H13, for example, has a minimum efficiency of 99.95%, measured at the particle size that is hardest to capture.

This is the principle behind HEPASAFE, the TAMA AERNOVA absolute filter for industrial extraction systems: a dry filtration system consisting of a single H13 absolute filtration stage according to EN 1822, designed to capture toxic and harmful dust generated by processes in the chemical and pharmaceutical sectors.

Unlike cartridge or bag filters, HEPASAFE does not use cleaning to regenerate the filter elements. The dust is separated and accumulated in the filter, which is replaced once spent: this is why it is called a "disposable filter". It is also why it works as a second barrier rather than as the main stage: the process dust load is handled by the primary filter, while HEPASAFE captures the residual fraction.

The air therefore passes first through the primary filtration stage and then through the absolute stage. The logic is simple: not to replace the main filter, but to add a further barrier when the analysis of the application calls for it.

HEPASAFE at a glance

  • Type: dry, disposable absolute filter (no regeneration of the filter elements)
  • Filtration class: H13 according to EN 1822
  • Configuration: single absolute filtration stage, installed downstream of the primary filtration
  • Filter element replacement: bag-in/bag-out system, with no contact with the dust
  • Applications: toxic and harmful dust in the chemical and pharmaceutical sectors

How do you replace an absolute filter without exposing the operator?

An absolute filter is replaced safely with a bag-in/bag-out system: the spent filter element is removed and sealed inside a bag, without the operator coming into contact with the accumulated dust.

This aspect is often overlooked at the design stage. A disposable filter, by definition, captures and concentrates dust inside it. With a highly potent active ingredient, the spent element contains the very substance the whole system is meant to protect people from.

Maintenance therefore becomes a critical point in the containment strategy. A machine can perform excellently in production and then expose the maintenance technician during the filter change.

HEPASAFE integrates a bag-in/bag-out system that allows easy, quick and safe removal of the filter elements, avoiding contact with the dust. Containment is thus maintained not only while the system is running, but also during maintenance.

When is an absolute filter really needed in a pharmaceutical plant?

An absolute filter is needed when the characteristics of the substance, the destination of the air or the risk assessment require an additional barrier downstream of the main filter; it should not be added automatically to every pharmaceutical system.

An absolute filtration stage should be considered, for example:

  • when handling highly potent active ingredients with particularly strict containment levels;
  • when the filtered air is returned to the working environment and specific requirements must be met;
  • when the risk assessment shows the need for an additional barrier downstream of the primary filtration;
  • when the process or the end customer requires verifiable containment performance;
  • when the consequences of a main filter failure make a second level of protection advisable.

The right question, then, is not "do I always need a HEPA filter?", but: what level of filtration is needed for this substance, this process and this containment target?

How do you verify that containment really works?

Containment performance is verified through tests in which the process is simulated using a safe, measurable surrogate substance, such as lactose, and air samples are taken at defined points around the work area. A widely used reference in the industry is the SMEPAC methodology described in the ISPE guidelines for assessing the containment performance of pharmaceutical equipment.

Extraction plays a decisive role in this balance: airflow, capture points, filtration and operating conditions must work as a single system.

Verification does not end at commissioning, either. Filter elements load up over time, operating conditions change and the same machine may process different products. Monitoring, maintenance and safe filter replacement become part of the containment strategy.

From isolator to exhaust: containment is a system

With highly potent pharmaceutical dust, protecting the operator at the point of processing is essential. But the dust's journey does not end once it is extracted.

Machine, capture, ductwork, main filter, any absolute filtration, the final destination of the air and filter maintenance are all part of the same system.

For anyone building machines and lines for the pharmaceutical industry, the question is not only "how do I contain the dust inside the machine?", but also "what happens to the dust after I have extracted it?"

This is where a second barrier such as HEPASAFE by TAMA AERNOVA completes the filtration strategy, when the application requires it, from system operation right through to the filter change.

Are you designing a machine or line for highly potent active ingredients?
Contact us

FAQ – Absolute filtration of pharmaceutical dust

Can an absolute filter replace a cartridge filter?

No. The two stages have different functions and work in sequence: the cartridge filter handles the process dust load and is cleaned periodically, while a disposable absolute filter such as HEPASAFE captures the residual fraction downstream, when the application requires it.

Can an absolute filter be added to an existing system?

Yes, it is often enough to add an absolute stage downstream of the main filter, without replacing the entire system. This happens when an existing line switches to a more potent active ingredient. The starting point is an analysis of the substance, airflow, existing filter, destination of the air and required containment level.

What is the difference between an H13 and an H14 HEPA filter?

According to EN 1822, an H13 filter has a minimum efficiency of 99.95% and an H14 filter 99.995%, both measured at the most penetrating particle size. HEPASAFE by TAMA AERNOVA is built in class H13.

Is an absolute filter needed if the air is discharged outside?

Discharging outside does not, on its own, determine whether an absolute stage is needed. The characteristics of the substance, the concentrations, the applicable emission requirements and the risk assessment must all be considered.

Can pharmaceutical dust be explosive?

Yes, some pharmaceutical dusts can form potentially explosive atmospheres when dispersed in air under the right conditions. The explosion risk must be assessed based on the characteristics of the dust and the process, taking into account the applicable ATEX requirements.